8/24/2023 0 Comments Gifted and talented program![]() Gifted programs should be expanded, not eliminated But taking opportunities from kids because they are too successful is a backward approach that will erode America’s competitive advantage in global science and technology.” - James S. The fact that some kids get ahead through discipline and hard work does not deny that opportunity to others who face the same choices. It’s unfair to deny students the chance to excel just because they’re ahead of their peers What message does that send black or Hispanic kids in advanced classes? That there aren’t enough people who look like you taking these classes, so you don’t deserve curriculum appropriate for your level?” - Karol Markowicz, New York Post “The idea that because students don’t represent the right racial mix, programs need to be scrapped is noxious. Racial representation isn’t the only measure of gifted programs’ success “Instead of seeing the racial and economic imbalance in gifted programs as a cry to expand methods of identifying giftedness in populations of children who are underserved by them, the solution is to toss out what works for some children because it doesn’t work for all children.” - James R. Many of the problems can be solved with better selection criteria They just cannot compete with the private school children without them.” - Tiana Lowe, Washington Examiner “For those underprivileged children dreaming of becoming surgeons, nurses, computer scientists, or climate scientists, they need the public school system to offer gifted options. Gifted programs give underprivileged children a chance to outcompete rich kids In this way, both the regular and the advanced benefit when there are different academic streams.” - John Barsby, Globe and Mail Time is limited, and it is usually the advanced who get neglected. ![]() “When students of all abilities are grouped together, the teacher is stretched to help the regular students while also challenging the advanced students. Perspectives Gifted program supportersĪll students benefit from gifted programs Adams's spokesman said he will “ assess” the de Blasio plan. Democratic nominee Eric Adams, the overwhelming favorite to be the next mayor when de Blasio’s term ends at the end of the year, has in the past defended gifted programs. Others reject the idea that it’s possible to even identify gifted children, since learning manifests itself in so many unquantifiable ways.Ī major question hanging over de Blasio’s move to end New York’s gifted and talented program is whether the city’s next mayor will follow through with the decision. In fact, they argue that doing so causes harm to both groups. Many experts also say there is very little research to back up claims that separating advanced students from their peers helps either group. Ĭritics say that, in practice, gifted programs largely serve to give an extra leg up to children who already enjoy significant advantages. Others say the way to address racial disparities in gifted education is to expand, not get rid of, the programs. ![]() Supporters often argue that it’s unfair to ask advanced students to stunt their own education because some of their classmates aren’t learning at the same pace. Why there’s debateĬonventional wisdom frames gifted programs as a benefit for all children because they provide exceptional students more room to flourish while at the same time giving teachers in typical classrooms more time to focus on students who need the most help. Like New York, a number of school districts in across the country have also begun to reconsider the value of placing high-performing students on a separate educational track from their peers. Depending on the district, gifted students may attend a separate school, be placed in a different class or have a certain number of hours of specialized instruction a week. There are no national standards for how they should be carried out, so the specifics vary substantially based on state and city standards. Programs that provide advanced academic instruction to high-performing students are offered in nearly every state.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |